Who's ready for another round of "Does EMS belong in the fire service?"?

     That long-running and always-passionate debate began a new chapter this summer with the release of a white paper from top fire organizations that argues that the fire service is best-equipped and suited to deliver prehospital EMS in the United States.

     What's notable about this paper-entitled Prehospital 9-1-1 Emergency Medical Response: The Role of the United States Fire Service in Delivery and Coordination-is that the case is made by three EMS physicians. The authors are Paul Pepe, MD, medical director for Dallas EMS and the metro Dallas BioTel systems; Franklin Pratt, MD, medical director for the Los Angeles County Fire Department; and Steven Katz, MD, EMT-P, associate medical director for Palm Beach County (FL) Fire Rescue.

     They wrote on behalf of Advocates for Fire Service-Based EMS, a coalition of major fire organizations dedicated to promoting fire-based EMS as the best model for prehospital emergency care. The coalition includes the IAFF, IAFC, National Volunteer Fire Council, Congressional Fire Services Institute and National Fire Protection Association.

     "We feel that EMS is at a crossroads, as the Institute of Medicine report pointed out, and that fire-based EMS is in the perfect position to help get past that crossroads in delivering first response," says Katz. "The fire service is strategically positioned to deploy to all kinds of hazards in 9-1-1 emergencies."

     That's one of the paper's key arguments: That victims of things like auto accidents, building collapses, hazmat incidents, etc., may need physical rescue in addition to urgent medical care. Often, nonfire EMS can't provide such rescue.

     "Early in my career, I was a volunteer paramedic on an ambulance squad in New York," recalls Katz. "We were dispatched to a car accident, which was typical back then-there was no fire service dispatch; the ambulance got dispatched to motor vehicle accidents. And there was a guy who was awake and talking and entrapped in his vehicle. It caught on fire, and I watched this guy burn to death when he was clearly not critically injured. Had we been a fire department responding, he likely would have survived."

     For the paper's other main points, see the sidebar. Meanwhile, the first major response came in an essay by EMS journalist John Becknell, publisher of Best Practices in Emergency Services.